His usually keen mind is now dulled behind the dust of old age. But Miss Sherlock made headlines for being the first adaptation to gender-swap both Holmes and Watson, with the late Japanese actress Yuko Takeuchi taking on the titular role. He played the role 41 times over a decade, and this entry is among his most enthralling in a rare story where Holmes' mental efforts stumble and force him into a corner relying solely on physical, morally suspect action. The cold, brilliant Holmes has been adapted literally hundreds of times and been played by more than 75 actors. The second of Doyle's four Holmes-centric novels has seen its share of adaptations, and each has made for nothing less than a competent telling of an intriguing tale. Trying to ruin Holmes is good, but Moriarty's ploy Holmes is a fraud who hired actors and made up cases! For the first time since 1893, when Conan Doyle killed off Holmes for the first time, the entire nation was talking about Sherlock Holmes. He is the son of actors Anna Lee and Alan Miller and the grandson of actor Bernard Lee. He and his older brother David were raised first in Dulwich Village, a south London suburb, and then later back in Surrey. 4. As is evidenced by its numerous appearances on this list it's safe to say that this is Doyle's most frequently adapted tale, and its ubiquitous nature has dampened some of its bite. The Case: With John Watson still recovering from his wife's death Sherlock publicly accuses a well-known personality of being a serial killer.Doyle? In addition to the expected Holmes-ian elements regarding his sharp displays of brilliance, the film also delivers conspiracy theories and a brutal conclusion that feels like a more literary take on 1970s conspiracy thrillers. (1991). It's good stuff made great, though, by the sheer power of emotion as these two friends, Holmes and Watson, find each other once more. Ian McKellen - Mr. Holmes (2015) Includes Film, Radio & TV. STYLE. Gene Wilder and Marty FeldmanRight off the bat, this movie should be far funnier than it is. 786,562 likes henrycavill #EnolaHolmes #Sept23 @Netflix view all 8,156 comments Add a comment Instagram Henry Cavill has become a well-established action star, best known for his performance as Superman in the DCEU. The film is an engaging enough mix of story turns and entertaining beats including the return of Irene Adler into Holmes' life and mind, but Cushing is its beating heart. Elementary (20122019, Holmes played Jonny Lee Miller) This is more of a U.S. version of Sherlock than a genuine Holmes adaptation (as signified by their decision to title the show after Holmess most famous quote-that-he-never-really-said), but it makes some bold moves of its own. Sherlock Holmes In The Movies: Ranking 70 Feature-Length Films Starring The Iconic Detective [Part Two] (Months ago, writer Rob Hunter set out on a wild and FINANCE. There are some fantastic back and forths between them as each moves a step ahead of the other, and while it mirrors his relationship with Moriarty in structure it exists with less vitriol and violence. It was all the more painful for the fact the year should have been a sort of annus mirabilis for its Watson, John C Reilly, who starred in The Sisters Brothers and Christopher Plummer and James MasonNo apologies here, but while you might expect an authentic Doyle adaptation and/or a colder Holmes portrayal to top the list there's just no way around this film's supremacy. Doyle! Read More:Famous Actors Who Started Out As Porn Stars. Fandom has a love-hate response to the Guy Ritchie adaptations. His appearance here is relatively brief, but he packs a punch in his actions and effect. Anthony Higgins and Debrah FarentinoFailed television pilots about Holmes in the present day are something of a subgenre unto themselves, but while most are mild mediocrities I'd be lying if I said I didn't have a ridiculous amount of fun with this one. Still, performances are good, action beats are mildly exciting, and that stained-glass knight remains a pretty damn cool effect. There's real drama in the acts of sabotage taking British lives, and it gives Holmes' investigation a strong sense of urgency beyond the fate of merely one or two people. The Case: The famed detective comes out of retirement to investigate some mysterious deaths and a missing prince.Doyle? This Amblin production is something of a cult favorite, and it has a strong pedigree in producer Steven Spielberg, director Barry Levinson, and writer Chris Columbus, but I'm still going to make the bold claim that it's merely okay. Just as terrible, if not worse, was the shift that Will Ferrell put in, which was sphincter-clenchingly unfunny. Doyle! Basil Rathbone and Nigel BruceI'm an admitted sucker for train-set thrillers as the tight location moving at high speeds promises all manner of suspenseful delights, and dropping Holmes into such a situation works beautifully. Michael Caine - Without a Clue (1988) A family curse and frightening canine attacks draw the duo to the countryside where they pursue the truth behind a recent murder and the promise of another, and it's an effective excursion into the fog-shrouded mystery that as usual with adaptations of this particular story only really suffers from less time with Holmes. Roll on the planned third instalment this December. Based on "A Scandal in Bohemia" (1891)Holmes and Watson? The similarities to 1987's, are curious same network, same cryogenics plot device, same female doctor sidekick but writer/director Kenneth Johnson (creator of, ) improves on the premise and delivers casually enjoyable entertainment in the tonal vein of. He's a fascinating creation on the page and rarely less captivating on the screen despite the varied nature of his incarnations over the years. The ending is equally miserable in its ignoble end for Moriarty and the utterly convoluted nature of Holmes' faked demise, but damn, the elements that work well really, really work. Holmes allusions are on point. Add in the fact that Downey can pull off the lazily jaded humour of an addict hes been there himself, after all and Guy Ritchies trademark whiplash editing and the Downey Holmes franchise deserves its plaudits. And, no, he wasnt very good either). Holmes & Watson was as fiendishly bad as its villain Moriarty (who, incidentally, was played by Ralph Fiennes. Peter Cushing and Andre MorellHammer Films are best known for their horror efforts with classic monsters and human killers, but one of their other efforts is also their sole entry into the Holmes canon. They appeared in dozens of films together and were close personal friends. Watson is more seasoned and is more than a match for our detective, who is suitably electrifying. The case and setting lend the show a terrifically gothic atmosphere, and there are a few legitimately creepy visual beats along the way. Ohh, I have already showered so many accolades over the last two entries. The Case: How could a woman shoot herself in the head,die, and then return to murder her husband?Doyle? Robert Downey Jr. and Jude LawGuy Ritchie's sequel to his own blockbuster reboot brings more action to the screen, and while it can't touch the first film it's an entertaining adventure all the same. The voice itself also carries an unnerving element that most villains would kill for especially as action beats build in their intensity. It plays like an Agatha Christie mystery as we're locked in with a set number of suspects for the great detective to make deductive mincemeat of, and he doesn't disappoint against a motley group of passengers while the train hurtles down the tracks. Basil Rathbone and Nigel BruceHolmes' first foray against the Nazis (and first to be visibly moved beyond his usual time period) is a terrifically tense thriller that presents a deadly enemy and a slow reveal to their identity. Now aged 93, McKellen's Holmes has long since retired from sleuthing, and as his memory slowly deteriorates, he finds himself dwelling on past cases. It's unfortunately not as every gag that lands is followed by two that don't, but it's still a ridiculous and fun affair. Basil Rathbone and Nigel BruceThe final Rathbone adventure is more of a suspense tale than a mystery as we know who's behind the thefts from early on. The Case: A curse, a hound, and the moors walk into a bar.Doyle? Doyle! Here we're given a Holmes long since retired and facing the greatest threat to his legendary mental acuity Alzheimer's. It's powerful stuff. Lucy Liu, left, as Dr. Joan Watson and Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock Holmes in Elementary.. Here are seven of the best actors who played Sherlock Holmes. To mark the occasion, we took a look back over some of the standout Sherlocks (good and bad) of the past and considered where Lloyd-Hughes take might fit with his predecessors. As mentioned, the beauty of Holmes on screen is often in the varied forms he takes. Glowing creatures in the marsh, a killer who's a master of disguise, and some of Bruce's most amusing beats as Watson help make this a fun and thrilling watch. By the old Baskerville estate.Doyle? A woman engaged to be married is blackmailed by a devious and greedy villain. The Case: A diplomat is blackmailed into joining Professor Moriarty's gang.Doyle? Known from: US TV series Elementary (2012). Plus, our list only includes live-action performances. Basil Rathbone was far from the first actor to play Sherlock Holmes on screen, but he was certainly the first to turn Sherlock into a star. NoHolmes and Watson? The theft of a music box is set to the tune of murder. Known from: ITV television series (1984) 4. His Holmes is odd, unsettling, and endlessly magnetic, and his chemistry with Martin Freeman's John Watson is unmatched. Hans Zimmer also turns in a terrifically lively score to round out the experience. as Holmes riffs with his new lady doctor friend, interacts with the world, and stumbles through the malleable nature of definitions and social mores. It's effective, to be sure, especially as the guilty parties overthink their plan in ways that backfire on them, but the resolution feels pretty light by the series' frequently more dramatic standards. Norwood played Holmes in 47 silent films, modelling himself on the classic illustration of the detective by Sidney Paget. A true method actor, Norwood studied the role with enormous diligence and brought a wonderful intensity to his portrayal both in film, opposite Hubert Willis as Watson, and on the stage. Its not hard to see why Brett might be considered the definitive televisual Holmes, at least by the generation brought up on Granada, which produced the series. Meanwhile, their Sherlock has the dismissive vibe of a louche hipster, a sort of tattooed layabout older brother who idolises Russell Brand (hes very much a supporting character here and doesnt even show up until episode four). Matt Frewer has been travelling all over North America in recent months filming recurring roles. A solid, if somewhat vanilla Holmes. Although most notable for personifying bloodsucking vampire, Dracula, on screen, he portrayed other varied characters on screen, most of which were villains, whether it Jonny (sometimes credited as Johnny) Lee Miller was born on November 15, 1972, in Kingston, England, UK. Upon leaving school, he decided to become a Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones. By. Sure Bruce's Watson is still a bit goofy but he proves useful in addition to earning some smiles. Brett is obviously fantastic, though, as he works through the possibilities in his effort to dismiss the idea of the undead, and his turn along with some wonderfully atmospheric visuals are the highlights of an otherwise iffy tale. The positives are made up mostly of Holmes' scenes with Moriarty as they crackle with energy, wit, and unpredictability. It was all the more painful for the fact the year should have been a sort of annus mirabilis for its Watson, John C Reilly, who starred in The Sisters Brothersand the masterful Stan & Ollie the same year. Believe me, I tried, but with the time and resources allotted, I've had to call it quits at 70. His calling card is a trail of snapped spines, so he makes for an interesting nemesis for the brainy detective. Its Holmes is a man so distraught with grief that he's come to believe he's actually the legendary crime-solver, and when his own brother tries to have him institutionalized a psychiatrist named Watson comes to his aid. No.Holmes and Watson? A dire excuse for a comedy that won four Razzies and thank God, in a way lost a lot of cash at the box office, Holmes & Watson was inflicted upon the world in 2018. Holmes is now in theaters. Wontner's first go as Holmes shows him to be a solid fit for Doyle's creation. Now that you know our methods, Watson, let us present EW's ranking of 10 of the best Sherlock Holmes actors of all time. The villain is cruel, the threat is real, and seeing Holmes in distress raises the drama immensely. The Case: Holmes and Watson investigate a serial murderer known as Jack the Ripper, and the clues lead them to England's highest seats of power.Doyle? The Case: An aging Holmes suffering from dementia struggles to recall his final case and a life built on fleeting memories.Doyle? A curse, a hound, and the moors walk into a bar. The Irregularsshares the same irreverence that Bridgerton recently demonstrated, including a willingness to overlay a hip-hop soundtrack onto shots of period London and cast non-white actors in petticoats. Loosely based on "The Adventure of the Musgrave Ritual" (1893), "The Adventure of the Three Garridebs" (1924), and "The Adventure of the Gloria Scott" (1893). Compromising photos threatening to scandalize the Queen lead Holmes into the presence of the first woman to truly catch his interest and who happens to hold the key to the pictures. didn't see you come in. Some prefer portrayals in line with Doyle's writings while others are open to performances that a bit more flexible, and someone somewhere is still probably pining for a Nicholas Rowe/Alan Cox reunion. There are some fantastic back and forths between them as each moves a step ahead of the other, and while it mirrors his relationship with Moriarty in structure it exists with less vitriol and violence. Someone or something is tearing out throats in Quebec, and only Sherlock Holmes has the stomach to catch the killer. It's good fun with the weakest element being the end that brings us back into the present. And then there was the writing. It's also worth noting that at 85 minutes it's the longest of the series, and there's not a wasted frame. Based on "The Adventure of the Empty House" (1903) and "The Final Problem" (1893)Holmes and Watson? No. NoHolmes and "Watson?" It's a shame as it's also one of the best adaptations of this story complete with terrifically atmospheric set-pieces, some fantastically Gothic beats, and another pairing of the great Cushing and Christopher Lee (as the new Lord Baskerville). Plummer and Mason are fantastic as Holmes and Watson, respectively, and both bring dramatic weight and real charisma to the characters even with the former being a more human detective than we often get. Nicol Williamson and Robert DuvallIt turns out Holmes' suspicions about Moriarty are the result of possible delusions caused by heavy drug use, so Watson arranges for the great detective to sit down with Sigmund Freud. Doyle! The Case: A fancy pearl is the target of ruthless thieves, villains, and murderers.Doyle? This 2020 Netflix film is all about Millie Bobby Brown's eponymous detective, the younger (and equally brilliant) sister of the famed Sherlock. Includes Film, Radio & TV.Select actors who played Holmes in a single film: The classic approach to making a particular take on Holmes and his enablers stand out is to flip a character in some dramatic way (Holmes is a woman! Based on The Hound of the Baskervilles (1902)Holmes and Watson? Zack Snyders Justice League is funereal, though most funerals are shorter than four hours. The Case: Is the Baskerville family cursed by a fearsome hound, or is something more evil behind the stream of deaths?Doyle? Its other highlight, though, and one that doesn't seem to get as much recognition, is Norman McKinnel's portrayal of Moriarty. Known from: Modern Sherlock adaptation (2009) and sequel (2011). MOBILE. He's old, frail, and cranky but still capable of displaying a twinkle in his eye as in the scene where he learns of Adler's presence and later tells her he is "never beaten twice.". Basil Rathbone and Nigel BruceThe action moves to Watson's homeland of Scotland which affords the film some attractive-ish scenery, but even as the story unfolds with bodies hitting the floor fairly frequently the resolution is a bit underwhelming. Downey Jr. and Law show great chemistry in their banter and interactions, and Ritchie crafts some fantastic action set-pieces as companions to scenes where Holmes' deductive efforts come to life. Based on "The Adventure of the Noble Bachelor" (1892)Holmes and Watson? James D'Arcy - Sherlock (2002 TV Movie) It follows the prequel norm in trying too hard to explain so many elements about Holmes' character, interests, outfit, etc. Jeremy Brett and Edward HardwickeI've said it before and I'll say it again if we ever meet in person, but Jeremy Brett is the best and most consistently exciting Sherlock Holmes. Based on The Hound of the Baskervilles (1901)Holmes and Watson? It turns out Holmes' suspicions about Moriarty are the result of possible delusions caused by heavy drug use, so Watson arranges for the great detective to sit down with Sigmund Freud. Alan Napier, The Adventure of the Speckled Band, Your Show Time (1949) 1. It's as if his entire personality was defined by this one incident, and rather than be thrilling it's instead far too convenient. By Evan Romano Published: Sep The story's less interesting as the focus here is Moriarty's greedy scheme to cause chaos and bolster his bank accounts yawn but Ritchie's eye for stylish visuals and the continued charm of Downey Jr. and Law go a long way towards making this worth a watch. What treachery is this? Trying to ruin Holmes is good, but Moriarty's ploy Holmes is a fraud who hired actors and made up cases! Add in Jude Law as a devoted John Watson, and the result is an action-packed adaptation that's pure popcorn fun. Line Of Duty coppers, ranked from least to most bent. 8 The Awakened. Still, performances are good, action beats are mildly exciting, and that stained-glass knight remains a pretty damn cool effect. The Case: Sherlock is forced to juggle both a recently acquitted Professor Moriarty and a woman whose life is in immediate danger.Doyle? As of 2012, he even holds the Guinness World Record for the most The film relies heavily on the unlikely but admittedly sexy theory known as the Royal Conspiracy, which posited that the Ripper was the royal physician Sir William Gull, who murdered five women to cover up an affair between Queen Victorias grandson, the Duke Of Clarence, and a Whitechapel prostitute (anyone who has read Alan Moores graphic novel masterpiece From Hell will be familiar with the details). He is definitely the most enduring and the most remembered and his impact to the future portrayals cant be denied. Doyle! The mystery itself is pretty straightforward with Moriarty running a counterfeiting scheme, but the laughs, action, and affection for the characters lifts it above the fray and make it a clearly superior inspiration for both 2009's. Known from: Hallmark TV movie adaptations (2000-2002). Downey Jr. is quick-witted, calculative and ruthless, and at the same time antisocial. He played Sherlock Holmes for the longest period of time over 200 times on radio itself. The film follows his attempt at recalling the details of his last case knowing only that he failed and it was the one that ended his career. Sure, the quality of the show itself could vary wildly (the less said about those final episodes, the better), but Cumberbatch elevates even the most ridiculous moments. After Young Sherlock comes Old Sherlock! The most famous fictional detective has a lot of interpretations to his name. Members of an exclusive club are being killed in violent ways, but is that just the price of membership? A young Michael Fassbender balances that out with his creepy, big-mouthed portrayal of the prime suspect. WebThe refined and debonair English actor Jeremy Brett will forever be best remembered for his long-running and critically acclaimed portrayal of Sherlock Holmes for Britain's Granada Television. But over the show's seven seasons, Elementary proved to have its own brilliance, a sharp, thoughtful take that relocated the detective to modern-day New York City. Hes not indifferent or disdainful to the feelings of others, like earlier versions of the character, but he does find them hard to interpret, and its an important difference. Despite the potential for this all to descend into pastiche, McKellen pulls it off with aplomb, giving one of the genuinely heartfelt and human interpretations of a traditionally ice-cold, unfeeling character. The film establishes duel plot lines destined to collide, and it manages some engaging set-pieces and sequences along the way. Doyle! Doyle! Mr. I would only be repeating what has already been said. He is best known as the creator of the screen image of Sherlock Holmes in the TV series The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, directed by Igor Maslennikov based on the works of Arthur Conan Doyle, for which in 2006 he was Rather than Sherlock Holmes has taken all sorts of unusual forms from a medical doctor (Hugh Laurie) to a washed-up actor (Michael Caine) to a literal dog (the Hayao Miyazaki-directed TV series Sherlock Hound). It's far more of a character drama than a thriller, but it's engaging all the same. The Case: With the real greatest detective out of town a minor case falls to his brother Sigerson.Doyle? To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. NoHolmes and Watson? From a privileged background, Brett was educated at England's most prestigious independent school, Eton Peter Wilton Cushing was born on May 26, 1913 in Kenley, Surrey, England, to Nellie Maria (King) and George Edward Cushing, a quantity surveyor. Loosely based on A Study in Scarlet (1887)Holmes and Watson? It's a beautifully made film with an engaging story, and McKellen brings real heart and sorrow to the role. The elements that work best, though, give the story a more darkly satisfying back half than the somewhat underwhelming one found in the original short story. A serial killer with a taste for stockings is targeting teenage daughters of aristocrats. Not really, but it does lift elements from "The Adventure of the Empty House" (1903), "The Disappearance of Lady Frances Carfax" (1911), and The Sign of Four (1890)Holmes and Watson? Loosely based on "The Adventure of the Dying Detective" (1913). Doyle! None of that is a knock either as it's supremely entertaining throughout. Jeremy Brett and Edward HardwickeThe second of Doyle's four Holmes-centric novels has seen its share of adaptations, and each has made for nothing less than a competent telling of an intriguing tale. If that appeals, so will this. It follows the prequel norm in trying too hard to explain so many elements about Holmes' character, interests, outfit, etc. Roger Moore - Sherlock Holmes in New York (1976) A big draw, though, is the always engaging Ida Lupino as the woman in trouble. WebThe cold, brilliant Holmes has been adapted literally hundreds of times and been played by more than 75 actors. Their banter is smart, fast, entertaining, and increasingly emotionally charged offering a usually strong balance to the methodical nature of the cases and writing. NoHolmes and Watson? It's good fun with the weakest element being the end that brings us back into the present. The Case: The detective is tasked with finding a missing bride, but he's distracted by a series of troubling and possibly prophetic dreams.Doyle? These actors did complete justice to the iconic character of Sherlock Holmes. The Case: After years of receiving pearls from an anonymous benefactor a young woman is asked to meet, and she brings Sherlock Holmes along for the ride.Doyle? Read More:Richest Actors in The Marvel Cinematic Universe. Known from: Hammer Horror-produced film and 1965 TV series, Actor | Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin FreemanThis first entry in the BBC's much-ballyhooed reboot does a terrific job introducing the characters to each other, to viewers, and to the 21st century. As far as young adult TV goes, the series hardly reinvents the wheel, but it does drastically reinterpret elements of the Holmes canon for a new generation. The island prison is a great setting, and Holmes' discovery of the truth behind his sister Eurus (Sian Brooke) builds some impressive emotional beats en route to a highly satisfying end. For all its faults, though, 1970s Wilder is a madman in his prime resulting in some beautifully orchestrated chaos. The Case: Members of an exclusive club are being killed in violent ways, but is that just the price of membership?Doyle? Sherlock Holmes is over 130 years old, which means there are quite a few interpretations of the famed detective out there, especially on screen. The detective has appeared on-screen over 250 times in total. In fact, Sherlock Holmes is the most played literary human character in history (according to the Guinness Book of World Records ). A leading man of prodigious talents, Peter O'Toole was born and raised in Leeds, Yorkshire, England, the son of Constance Jane Eliot (Ferguson), a Scottish nurse, and Patrick Joseph O'Toole, an Irish metal plater, football player and racecourse bookmaker. could be so easily fact-checked and proven wrong as to be annoying when no one does so. Side note and possible spoiler, while one of the more common refrains from the BBC's popular reboot sees Holmes saying "It's never twins" this other BBC production didn't get the memo. The villain is cruel, the threat is real, and seeing Holmes in distress raises the drama immensely. Based on the play Sherlock Holmes (1899) co-written by William GilletteHolmes and Watson? Netflixs The Irregulars is giving us a new Sherlock to join the legions of Holmeses past. His first appearance in particular is fairly intimidating with a scarf covering the lower half of his face, and his shift from restrained menace to fierce villainy is highly effective. Based on "The Adventure of Charles Augustus Milverton" (1904). Trying to ruin Holmes is good, but Moriarty's ploy Holmes is a fraud who hired actors and made up cases! He's old, frail, and cranky but still capable of displaying a twinkle in his eye as in the scene where he learns of Adler's presence and later tells her he is "never beaten twice.". Here, theyre reinvented as a rather modern handful of teenagers who spend their time investigating paranormal shenanigans. Unfortunately, that resolution involves hypnosis of sorts which is never more than dull. Sherlock is forced to juggle both a recently acquitted Professor Moriarty and a woman whose life is in immediate danger. The cold, brilliant Holmes has been adapted literally hundreds of times and been played by more than 75 actors. As of 2012, he even holds the Guinness World Record for the most-portrayed literary human character in the history of film and television. The final episode of the BBC's Sherlock Holmes reboot serves both a fantastic conclusion and a tease leaving viewers wanting more, and as is the case with other eps in the show it walks a fine line between strong style, affecting emotion, and a sloppy embrace of the illogical. We take this moment to list down the actors who played Sherlock Holmes portrayals. Based on "His Last Bow" (1917)Holmes and Watson? The missing films consist mostly of non-English adaptations I was unable to find subtitled (or at all) and a handful of TV movies that remained elusive and out of my reach. Its Holmes is a man so distraught with grief that he's come to believe he's actually the legendary crime-solver, and when his own brother tries to have him institutionalized a psychiatrist named Watson comes to his aid. NoHolmes and Watson? The elements that work best, though, give the story a more darkly satisfying back half than the somewhat underwhelming one found in the original short story. It's a minor drag getting there as Holmes' dream-fueled daze distracts from his more reliably entertaining antics, but as you've undoubtedly heard Brett is the absolute best version of the character. The story's less interesting as the focus here is Moriarty's greedy scheme to cause chaos and bolster his bank accounts yawn but Ritchie's eye for stylish visuals and the continued charm of Downey Jr. and Law go a long way towards making this worth a watch. as Holmes riffs with his new lady doctor friend, interacts with the world, and stumbles through the malleable nature of definitions and social mores. Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin FreemanThe final episode of the BBC's Sherlock Holmes reboot serves both a fantastic conclusion and a tease leaving viewers wanting more, and as is the case with other eps in the show it walks a fine line between strong style, affecting emotion, and a sloppy embrace of the illogical. Failed television pilots about Holmes in the present day are something of a subgenre unto themselves, but while most are mild mediocrities I'd be lying if I said I didn't have a ridiculous amount of fun with this one. But over seven seasons of Elementary, it was Miller who carved out his own memorable modern-day take on Holmes, a recovering English opiate addict in New York, with a little help from Lucy Lius Joan Watson and Natalie Dormers Jamie Moriarty (remember what we said about flipping the characters dramatically?). What? Arthur Wontner and Ian FlemingWontner's first go as Holmes shows him to be a solid fit for Doyle's creation. A highly skilled actor, Jeremy Brett showed us nuances in his portrayal that will be sorely missed. Doyle! It's a beautifully made film with an engaging story, and McKellen brings real heart and sorrow to the role. Brett is obviously fantastic, though, as he works through the possibilities in his effort to dismiss the idea of the undead, and his turn along with some wonderfully atmospheric visuals are the highlights of an otherwise iffy tale. Right off the bat, this movie should be far funnier than it is. Doyle! The first known portrayal of Sir Arthur Conan Doyles detective par excellence Sherlock Holmes on film is a 30-second piece of silent footage dating to sometime around 1900 named Sherlock Holmes Baffled. From his look to his mannerisms, he fits the character well as written, and he becomes the film's core strength. Side note and possible spoiler, while one of the more common refrains from the BBC's popular reboot sees Holmes saying "It's never twins" this other BBC production didn't get the memo. The Case: The theft of a music box is set to the tune of murder.Doyle? Hollywood storylines are now incorporating Covid-19 but is that a good thing? Doyle! Cumberbatchs steely, cerebral and no-nonsense detective comes so close to the one of the books. Doyle! It's as if his entire personality was defined by this one incident, and rather than be thrilling it's instead far too convenient. Loosely based on "The Adventure of the Six Napoleons" (1904)Holmes and Watson? In three of them, Rathbones Holmes even set his wits against Nazis, tracking down and apprehending thinly fictionalised versions of the Gestapo and Lord Haw-Haw. The Case: The devious Professor Moriarty is attempting to start a war in Europe, and that's not cool.Doyle? Based on "The Adventure of the Six Napoleons" (1904)Holmes and Watson? The sorely-missed Jeremy Brett was a genuine one-off an actor of immense skill and intense 2. A rash of serial suicides have hit London with seemingly unrelated people taking their lives in the same way, but Sherlock suspects it's actually murder. Setting an episode in Victorian times Holmes' original time-frame could easily have felt like a gimmick, but couching it in a "mind palace" excursion works to transport viewers back in time with minimal questions or concerns. The Case: John and Mary's wedding sees Sherlock deduce a murder plot while giving his best man speech.Doyle? Caine in particular is perfection as the drunken, womanizing, and nearly idiotic Holmes. Basil Rathbone Actor | A modern update of the story where Doyle infamously "killed" Sherlock Holmes. The refined and debonair English actor Jeremy Brett will forever be best remembered for his long-running and critically acclaimed portrayal of Sherlock Holmes for Britain's Granada Television. A big draw, though, is the always engaging Ida Lupino as the woman in trouble. Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones. Based on "The Adventure of the Empty House" (1903) and "The Final Problem" (1893). From his look to his mannerisms, he fits the character well as written, and he becomes the film's core strength. ago Unbiased answer: me. The perfect combination of genius and arrogance, Sherlocks Sherlock reintroduced an entire generation of British teenagers to Conan Doyles creation, expertly updating the franchise without it ever feeling forced (the series also represented Andrew Scotts break into the mainstream, for which we will be eternally grateful: without his twisted, preening Moriarty, theres no sexy priest). Hints of Moriarty's presence in previous episodes finally reveal the man himself here, and it was worth the wait. Hammer Films are best known for their horror efforts with classic monsters and human killers, but one of their other efforts is also their sole entry into the Holmes canon. Seeing Holmes knocked a bit off balance is equally worth the price of admission. Andrew Scott's portrayal of the master criminal is as perfect a blend of charisma and evil as you could hope for, and he creates a tremendous counterpoint for Holmes. The pieces of the plot are dripped throughout, though, and while it makes for one of the easier cases in which to pinpoint the players of course Watson's disgraced military friend is the target, obviously the photographer is involved, etc the slowly rising tension successfully holds our attention and growing excitement. The fun comes in Holmes' journey to the truth, and his realization that a deviously talented actress (played by Ursula Eileen Patricia Augusta Fraser Morison) is behind it all comes with an intriguing display of respect for her abilities. None of that is a knock either as it's supremely entertaining throughout. And broadly, it worked, given Downey is the perfect balance of annoying and charismatic to keep things fun. Yahoo Style Yahoo Style . Viewers knew immediately that they were in store for a more humorous and less competent Watson. Doyle! It's not the first time Holmes faced the Ripper (see 1965's A Study in Terror), but it's easily the best, and knowing it's from the director of Black Christmas (1974), Porky's (1981), and A Christmas Story (1983) just makes it all the more impressive. My personal ranking of every actor who has played the famous detective more than once. Loosely based on "The Adventure of the Musgrave Ritual" (1893), "The Adventure of the Three Garridebs" (1924), and "The Adventure of the Gloria Scott" (1893)Holmes and Watson? This version sticks closer than most to the book, and while that's a positive in theory it also leaves us with a healthy chunk of the tale told in flashback as well as the presence of a pointy-toothed native for better or worse. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. A solidly mid-table entry into the Premier League of Sherlock adaptations, the stars here are its titular gang, the Baker Street Irregulars, those urchins who act as Sherlocks network of informants in some of Sir Arthur Conan Doyles stories. The top 10 portrayals of Sherlock Holmes 1. NoHolmes and Watson? It plays like an Agatha Christie mystery as we're locked in with a set number of suspects for the great detective to make deductive mincemeat of, and he doesn't disappoint against a motley group of passengers while the train hurtles down the tracks. MOVIES. The British actor played Holmes multiple times over the years, but he was never better than in the 1959 film The Hound of the Baskervilles. For viewers who like their Holmes playing host to all manner of diagnosable personality disorders the character brought to life by Cumberbatch is heaven-sent. His portrayals in the 1959 The Hound of the Baskervilles was his first but he is remembered for the long running BBC series Arthur Conan Doyles Sherlock Holmes.. This series two finale is split so evenly between brilliance and disappointment that it makes its placement in this ranking difficult.

Count Days Between Dates, Advanced Psychiatry Associates Yelp, Moto G5 Keeps Restarting, Motorola Lapdock Raspberry Pi, Appalachian Kentucky Poverty, Parking Spot Weekly Rate, Toshiba Fire Tv Sound Settings Greyed Out, Persona 4 Nanako Dungeon,